Stock up on the most versatile, comfortable, and stylish pairs of black heels.
While we would never play favorites with our shoes, there might be one type that gets the most love: your black heels.
Ready to shop? You’ve landed on the right article to discover the 14 best black heels with what to look for and why we have selected each pair.
Pumps, slingbacks, kitten heels, wedges, and heeled sandals; no matter the kind, black heels will be among the most worn shoes in your closet.
Not only are they classic and always in style, but they will also add a few extra inches to your height.
Since it’s a popular shoe style, there is also a wide variety to shop from with various heights, toe shapes, and soles.
Styling Black Heels
The beauty of black heels are versatile and go with anything in your closet.
Wide-leg jeans and a retro printed top, a sleek short suit, or a floral printed prairie dress, black heels are a finishing touch that consistently works.
Owning more than one style of black heels will create a well-rounded shoe collection to ensure you’ll always have the correct shoe that matches your outfit for any occasion or season.
RELATED: 14 Best White Heels for Walking
What to Look for
Material: The most comfortable shoe styles are crafted from soft materials like leather or suede. Other materials like wool, patent leather, or synthetic also make great options but could be stiff.
Fit: Heels should fit snugly on your foot so that you don’t trip and fall.
Size: Check retailer reviews, but you should stick to your regular shoe size. That said, if you’re looking for a more sleek and less ethereal silhouette, go for shorter lengths or lighter-weight materials.
Ahead, check out 14 of the best black heels for you to find your new pair.
Our Top Picks
A black pump is a classic shoe style everyone needs in their closet. This style from Italian shoemaker M.Gemi is crafted in soft suede and has the quintessential pump shape.
One reviewer shares, “This shoe is gorgeous… wore it straight from the box! Very comfortable and no breaking in. This shoe goes with everything and anything. The heel height is perfect with skirts, pants and jeans.”
With your go-to black suit for a job interview or a fitted black shift dress for cocktails, this pair will get lots of mileage.
Material: Italian kid suede upper and soft leather lining
Sizes: IT 35-42
If you are on the hunt for comfortable black pumps, this block heel pair has lots of details, making it worth the splurge. The round-toe pump includes arch support and extra padding.
One of the best reviews exclaims, “These are probably the most comfortable heels of this height I’ve ever owned. They fit like a dream. The arch support is incredible.”
It’s also an eco-friendly heel made with recycled leather and biodegradable materials and created using less water.
Helpful Tip! The brand recommends ordering 1/2 size up.
Material:Triple-dyed Italian suede and leather lining
Sizes: IT 34-43
Slim and sleek, this pointy-toe stiletto features a slingback strap. This creates a secure fit, so you’ll never slip out of the pump.
This black heels got great reviews and one said, “It’s a really well-made shoes as others have said. It might be the comfiest shoes I have ever wear in these tall heels.”
With midi dresses or cropped denim, it will elevate any outfit.
Helpful Tip! Adjustable slingback strap.
Material: Leather upper, synthetic lining, rubber sole
When wearing your go-to favorite LBD, it’s always a good idea to pick a pair of fun black heels to complement.
Available on Amazon, these black heels got more than 3K great reviews. One raves, “The bow on the back is super cute, and the strap around the ankle can move from one side to the other, making it very easy to put on and take off.”
The bow on the back of these high heels makes them special and ready for any event. An ankle strap will provide a secure fit so you can walk or dance the night away with ease.
Material: soft faux suede
For a sexy black heel option, try a D’Orsay style, which will show off some skin. Adding to the appeal is the gold-colored 4-inch heel.
Buyers noted how comfortable these were and how they loved the shine. One of the reviewer said, “These shoes are everything. They are so elegant, classic yet sexy. True to size and very comfortable.”
If you are looking for what to wear with your white cocktail dress, this is it!
Material: Leather, patent leather or glitter fabric upper
When considering splurging on an item for your closet, a timeless pair of black heels are always the way to go. This gorgeous black mule will be a staple in your wardrobe for years.
Subtle YSL logo design with a shiny gold link detail in front these slides are dressy and wearable with a height of just over 2 inches.
Wear your favorite summer skirt with this to dress up easily.
Material: Black twill
Sizes: IT 36-42
The best part about a block heel is that that creates a stable base for easy walkability.
The shoe has a classic shape with a shiny croc-embossed design, an elastic trim that provides a secure fit, and a padded footbed for a comfortable step.
The 1.4-inch block heel is accented in a gold trip lending a luxe look. This black block-heeled shoe will pair beautifully with black pants or straight-leg jeans.
Material: Leather upper and lining, synthetic sole
A low heel and double strap create a black sandal that is beyond versatile. Wear dresses, jeans, pants, and skirts—there is nothing this ankle strap heel won’t work with it all.
Many reviewers noted, “Doesn’t squish my toes” or “Very comfortable in toe areas.”
Easy to purchase on Amazon and under $25 with over 7K reviews, buying this black strappy heel is a no-brainer.
Material: 100% polyurethane
Sizes: 5-15 with wide options
Peep-toe heels have a retro look that is always in style. Cole Haan shoes are filled with comfort details, and this 3-inch heel is no exception with foam inside and platform sole.
The exposed toe is flattering and will give you a great excuse to book your next pedicure.
Material: suede leather upper and printed polyurethane midsole
Are you heading on a spring break or resort getaway? Buy the perfect warm-weather shoe—an espadrille wedge.
The black canvas fabric combines with the jute raffia to create a versatile shoe that is easy to wear. Come summer, you’ll be reaching for these on the regular.
Material: poplin canvas & jute, leather insole, and rubber outsole
Platform heels are another timeless style that will add height without the pain. These give you 4.5 inches, with the feel of 3.5 inches.
This stylish black heels are voted as the #1 women’s platform sandals on Amazon. The buckle closure will hold your foot securely. These are the perfect pair of shoes to wear with your ultra flare jeans.
Features are trending, so let your feet get in on the action with these fluffy faux fur high heels.
Suede material keeps the fit comfortable and flexible, so you can walk confidently and let the feathers float you from location to location.
Pair with cropped pants or midi or mini-length dresses so these remain on full display.
Material: suede outer material, details of decision quality, breathable and soft fluffy feather
Wedges usually have a resort or casual feel, but the heel on this pair is sleek and elevated. These black wedges will take you from the office to drinks with height minus the discomfort.
A slingback strap will help keep these firmly on your feet, while cushion insoles will keep feet happy for a full day’s wear.
Material: 100% calf leather
Sizes: IT 35-41
Strappy sandals are ideal for special events like weddings and cocktail parties, or even just fun nights out.
This black strappy pair has a chunky heel that is sturdy and supportive. The ankle strap and the crisscross front create a fit and look that goes with virtually any dress.
Material: leather upper and lining, synthetic sole
When building a wardrobe of multiple pairs of black heels, get a variety of heel heights.
For example, a strappy sandal that is 3.5 inches, a pump that is 2 inches, a kitten heel mule, and a wedge.
Then no matter what height you’re feeling, you’ll be covered.
What are the most comfortable heels to wear?
Lower heels tend to be more comfortable as do more supportive styles like wedges and chunky or block heels.
What is the new trend in heels?
Wedges, pointy toes, kitten heels, and Mary Janes are currently trending for 2023.
Should heels feel tight or loose?
Heels should be on the snug side. If heels are too loose, you can walk out of them, and too tight, they will squeeze your toes and cause pain.
Should you buy high heels a half size bigger?
There is no straightforward rule for sizing heels. When you find a pair you want to buy, check out the comments section and read reviews from buyers since they often advise on sizing.
When buying online, order a few sizes to ensure you get the right fit.
All products featured on Viva Cabana are independently selected by our editorial team, and the company may earn commission through affiliate links.